Comparison
Mayra - Order Edit & Upsell vs Order Editing
A mature, highly rated self-serve editing and upsell app with deep fulfillment integrations.
The short version
Order Editing (OrderEditing.com) is a mature, highly rated app (5.0 from about 297 reviews) that covers self-serve editing, add and remove, cancellation, and upsells, with deep fulfillment integrations and plans from $99 to $599 per month. Mayra matches that core and adds cancellation deflection with store credit and merchant-controlled refund approvals, free while in early access. Choose Order Editing for its integrations and track record; choose Mayra to deflect cancellations, control refunds, and start free.
What Order Editing is
Order Editing, at OrderEditing.com, is a self-serve editing and post-purchase upsell app rated 5.0 from about 297 reviews on the Shopify App Store. Customers can change the address, edit quantities and variants, add or remove items, and cancel, with edit windows and fulfillment holds. It emphasises deep fulfillment integrations (100+, including Celigo, NetSuite, and ShipStation) and serves brands from roughly 100 up to 20,000 orders a month.
Shopify App Store rating: 5.0 from ~297 reviews
Pricing: Paid plans by order volume: Basic $99/mo (100-2,500 orders), Standard $199/mo (2,500-5,000), Professional $399/mo (5,000-10,000), and Enterprise $599/mo (10,000-20,000), each with a 7-14 day free trial. Address validation is an optional add-on.
Side by side
| Capability | Mayra - Order Edit & Upsell | Order Editing |
|---|---|---|
| Self-serve edits (address, quantity, variant) | Yes | Yes |
| Add items from the catalogue | Yes | Yes |
| Remove items | Yes | Yes |
| Self-serve order cancellation | Yes | Yes |
| Cancellation deflection with store credit | Yes | Not listed |
| Post-purchase upsells | Yes | Yes |
| Configurable edit window | Yes | Yes |
| Fulfillment hold during edits | Yes | Yes |
| Refund approval controls | Yes | Not listed |
| Automatic settlement through Shopify | Yes | Yes |
Where Mayra goes further
Cancellation deflection that saves the sale
When a customer starts a cancellation, Mayra can offer store credit to keep the order instead of refunding it. You set the bonus as a percentage of order value, cap the monthly spend, and set a credit expiry, with configurable cancellation reasons. Order Editing's App Store listing doesn't mention a built-in store-credit deflection flow.
Merchant-controlled refund approvals
Mayra holds any refund above a threshold you set in an approvals queue until you sign off, so nothing changes on the order and no refund is owed until you approve. Order Editing's listing doesn't mention a refund-approval workflow.
Free during early access
Order Editing's plans run from $99 to $599 per month by order volume. Mayra is free while in early access, and built for stores of any size on Shopify Basic, Advanced, or Plus.
See the full list of Mayra features for everything it does.
Who should choose which
Choose Order Editing if
Order Editing is a strong fit if you want a proven, highly rated app (5.0 from ~297 reviews) with deep fulfillment integrations (100+, including Celigo, NetSuite, and ShipStation), and you're comfortable with plans from $99 to $599 per month.
Choose Mayra if
Mayra is a better fit if you want cancellation deflection with store credit and merchant-controlled refund approvals on top of editing and upsells, and a tool that's free while in early access and works for stores of any size.
Frequently asked questions
Is Mayra a good alternative to Order Editing?
Yes. Mayra matches Order Editing's core self-serve editing, add and remove, cancellation, and post-purchase upsells, and adds cancellation deflection with store credit and merchant-controlled refund approvals. It is free while in early access.
Does Order Editing let customers cancel orders and remove items?
Yes. Order Editing's Shopify App Store listing includes order cancellation and adding or removing items, along with address, quantity, and variant edits, edit windows, and fulfillment holds.
Does Order Editing offer cancellation deflection with store credit?
Order Editing's App Store listing doesn't mention built-in store credit or a refund-approval workflow. Mayra offers cancellation deflection with a merchant-set store-credit bonus, monthly budget, and expiry.
How much does Order Editing cost compared to Mayra?
Order Editing's plans run from $99 per month (100-2,500 orders) to $599 per month (10,000-20,000 orders), each with a free trial. Mayra is free while in early access.
Order Editing details are based on its Shopify App Store listing and public information, as of August 2026, and may have changed since. "Not listed" means a capability isn't stated in Order Editing's public materials, not that it is necessarily absent.
See Mayra for yourself
Mayra brings self-serve order editing, cancellation deflection, and post-purchase upsells to your Shopify store. Free while in early access.